# 建立競品情報知識庫

這是三個檔案的虛構練習：把 HarborDesk 的能力宣稱和有日期的計畫放在一起比較，再寫出採購者可以複核的謹慎說法。

## 任務

只根據三個來源檔，分類每項能力宣稱，和有日期的產品計畫比較，並寫出不暗示目前可用的說法。保留需要人工審查的決定，每個結論都用 [[filename]] 引用。

## 預期推理

把 SAML、稽核記錄匯出與速率限制都視為尚未驗證的供應商宣稱。有日期的計畫只把 SAML 放在 2026 年第四季，稽核匯出沒有承諾，速率限制未指定；任何比較文案都要由負責人核准。

## 完整來源資料包

### HarborDesk comparison-page capture — competitor-claim.md

```markdown
# HarborDesk comparison-page capture

Capture date: 2026-09-01. This is a fictional marketing-page excerpt created for teaching.

HarborDesk's comparison page says the product offers SAML single sign-on, exportable audit logs, and an API limit of 1,000 requests per minute. The page does not show a plan name, release version, test result, or implementation evidence. Treat each sentence as a vendor claim, not an independently verified capability.
```

### HarborDesk product plan — dated internal note — dated-product-plan.md

```markdown
# HarborDesk product plan — dated internal note

Note date: 2026-08-20. This fictional note says SAML single sign-on is planned for Q4 2026. Exportable audit logs are discussed but have no committed delivery date. The API rate limit is not specified.

A plan is not a release record. No source here verifies that any listed capability is available to a customer on the capture date.
```

### Capability comparison review notes — comparison-review-notes.md

```markdown
# Capability comparison review notes

The comparison-page capture is the only direct statement of the three capabilities, and it is undated as a product release. The dated plan constrains what can be said about timing but does not confirm delivery.

A reviewer may label SAML as a vendor claim with a dated plan reference. Audit-log export and the 1,000-requests-per-minute limit remain unverified. A human owner must decide whether the evidence is strong enough for a comparison table; do not turn the plan into a promise.
```

## Reference answer: separate capability claims from delivery evidence

The comparison page makes three fictional vendor claims, while the dated plan only places SAML in a Q4 2026 plan and leaves audit-log export and the rate limit uncommitted or unspecified. None is a verified current capability; a human reviewer must decide how to present the comparison.

# HarborDesk — comparison reference

## Evidence status

The 2026-09-01 comparison page claims SAML single sign-on, exportable audit logs, and a 1,000-requests-per-minute API limit. It supplies no plan, release, or test evidence, so these remain vendor claims rather than verified current capabilities. [[competitor-claim.md]]

The 2026-08-20 plan places SAML in Q4 2026, discusses audit-log export without a committed date, and does not specify the rate limit. A plan is not a release record. [[dated-product-plan.md]]

## Warranted wording

A comparison can label SAML as a vendor claim with a dated Q4 2026 plan reference. Audit-log export and the rate limit should be marked unverified. A human owner must decide whether that evidence belongs in a published comparison; no capability should be presented as a current fact. [[comparison-review-notes.md]] [[competitor-claim.md]]

## 變更後來源

### dated-product-plan.md

```markdown
# HarborDesk product plan — dated internal note, revision 2

Note date: 2026-09-04. This fictional note says SAML single sign-on moved to a Q1 2027 target. Exportable audit logs are explicitly outside the current committed plan. The API rate limit is still not specified.

A plan is not a release record. No source here verifies that any listed capability is available to a customer on the capture date.
```

## 變更預期

The reference's Q4 2026 SAML plan becomes stale and must change to the revised Q1 2027 target. Exportable audit logs are now explicitly outside the current committed plan, while the rate limit remains unspecified. The marketing claims are still unverified, and a human reviewer still decides whether to publish a comparison.

## 審查邊界

逐項核對宣稱的日期與證據類型：比較頁是宣稱，產品計畫不是發佈紀錄。速率限制和稽核匯出仍未驗證，文案由比較負責人決定。

## 比較

一個虛構競品可以用幾個檔案手動核對。當有日期的截圖、路線圖修訂與信心標記需要保持連結，又不能把計畫寫成產品承諾時，來源連結的情報 wiki 才有幫助。

## 閱讀本地化頁面

https://wenlan.app/zh-TW/learn/build-competitive-intelligence-knowledge-base